Mariia Pukhka
Scientific Advisor –
Candidate of
sciences
Solov’yova O. V.
STUDENTS’ TYPICAL ERRORS IN ESL WRITTEN DISCOURSE
Topicality: Writing in English can be a
challenging task for students who learn English as a second language. Some ESL
students' social and cultural background prevents them from writing about
subjects they consider taboo, like politics or religion. Students may also
experience difficulties with form, morphology, vocabulary and syntax that are
different in English and their native language.
The present
paper describes possible problems in teaching ESL writing and the ways of their
solution.
Historiography: The
problem of teaching writing to ESL students has been studied by such scientists
as Ye. Kazarova, G. Krivchikova, L. Mazunova, S. Nikolayeva, A. Boyko, T. Hedge et alta. However,
writing still remains the least developed among the basic foreign language
skills. This gives us grounds to assert the novelty of this topic.
The Object is teaching writing
to ESL students.
The aim of the work is to study the main
peculiarities of teaching written discourse skills to ESL students.
According to the aim, the
investigation poses and fulfills the following objectives:
1. To describe the formation of written
discourse skills.
2. To study the main components of writing
proficiency.
3. To investigate the grammatical, strategic,
sociolinguistic and discourse competences.
4. To analyze the possible problems of
teaching writing and the ways of their solution.
5. To describe the main strategies for teaching
writing.
6. To develop some tasks for teaching
specific forms of writing in English.
The purpose of the research is to study the possible problems in teaching
writing and find the ways of their solution.
Writing plays an important role in the life of every person. It is
used in different spheres of people’s activity. Thus, it should be taught from
early stages of language learning. If speaking is a means of communication with
the help of sounds, writing is a means of communication with the help of
graphical sounds. Writing can be one of the most difficult aspects of ESL
teaching. Because of the complexities of writing, many teachers simply avoid
the area, instead concentrating on reading and pronunciation. Writing is,
however, essential to ESL students, especially those at higher levels, and
while it may be hard to get started teaching it, the rewards are more than
worth it. [3,147]
To
assist students in gaining more confidence in writing, teachers should let
students understand their actual level of English. Reassurance and motivation
are also of great importance.
Teaching
Writing is a complex and timely process. There are different writing activities
for beginning, intermediate, advanced, and transitional levels. Among the
beginning level activities are copying with understanding, sentence
completions, dictations, experience charts, everyday communications, situational
dialogues (rejoinders), development of original sentences, sentence
combinations, sentence expansion, summaries, controlled compositions, and
guided compositions. Among the intermediate level activities are summaries,
ordering of statements, completion of forms, friendly letters, outlining,
creative or recreational writing, and reactions. Advanced level activities
include expansion of previous writing assignments, book reports, business
letters, letters of complaint, reporting, and thematic compositions.
Transitional level activities include continuation of letter writing,
persuasive composition, expository compositions, and cloze practice.
Teaching
writing to students of a foreign language department should include practice in
producing formal and informal letters, resumes, cover letters, letters of
recommendation and different types of essays.
This
article deals with the typical errors we have found in the works by first-year
and second-year students of the College of Modern European Languages at Yuri
Fedkovych Chernivtsi National University. Specific forms of writing (formal,
informal, and essay writing) are also analyzed here.
We have analyzed
samples of written work done by first-year and second-year students of the
Department of Modern Foreign Languages at Yuri Fedkovych Chernivtsi National
University. We have grouped into several categories the most common mistakes we
have observed in the works.
1. Nouns
o
Omission of the -s plural (two
university)
o
Pluralizing non-countable nouns (homeworks)
o
Using indefinite article a(n) with a non-countable noun (a flour, a wine is good to drink)
o
Failing to make nouns and noun determiners agree (this doctors, seven page)
2. Verbs
o
Omission of 3rd person singular "s" (he walk)
o
Omission of the "ed" of the simple past tense (Yesterday he play ball)
o
Omission of the "ed" in formation of passive voice (The scientists were honor for their work)
o
Use of intransitive verbs in passive forms (The earthquake was occurred last Friday) - verbs such as occur, happen, sleep, die, and fall often cause problems because they
seem to have passive meanings even though they are intransitive.
o
Misuse of progressive verb forms (I
am reading the paper every day, What are you wanting?) - it can help to
emphasize that certain verbs expressing a state of being or mental activity are
generally not used in the progressive sense. Examples include appear, believe, have, hear, know, like,
need, see, seem, taste, think, understand, and want.
o
Misuse of perfect forms - while English uses present perfect to describe
an action that began in the past and continues to the present, as in "I
have been here for six months now," other languages would just say "I
am here six months now." Other students may omit the -ed ending on the
past participle: Many churches have offer
shelter to the homeless.
o
Misuse of modal auxiliaries - Out of the twenty-three English helping
verbs, nine, called modals, can only work as helping verbs. These are can, could, may, might, must, shall, should,
will, and would; verbs that can
be either helping or main verbs are forms of do, have, and be. Some
students may have trouble coordinating helping and main verbs, but it can help
to tell students that modal auxiliaries do not agree in number with the subject
(He cans do it) and that modals are
followed by base, not finite verb forms (He
can does it).[7,163]
3. Preposition Errors
o
Preposition meanings are highly idiosyncratic from language to language
- (I prefer to live in home, at the day
of her arrival)
4. Articles
o
Failing to use a(an) with singular countable nouns whose specific
identity is unknown to the reader (Mary
Beth arrived in limousine)
o
Using a(an) with non-countable nouns (a sugar, a furniture, a patience) Commonly used uncountable nouns
include words for food and drink (bacon,
beef, candy, milk, pasta); nonfood substances (air, water, coal, snow); abstract nouns (advice, anger, intelligence, fun); and others (biology, clothing, luggage, homework, furniture, money, news, work)
o
Failing to use the with nouns
whose specific identity is known to the reader (Gun on top shelf was loaded, Don't slam door when you leave)
o
Using the with plural or
uncountable nouns meaning "all" or "general" (In some parts of the world, the rice is
preferred to other grains.)
o
Using an article with proper nouns (the
South America, the Lake Geneva) - this can be confusing because some proper
nouns do take an article (the Mississippi
River, the Sahara Desert). The best strategy is to check the dictionary, an
atlas, or an encyclopedia when in doubt.
5. Adverb Clauses
o Misconstructing
adverb clauses by using two conjunctions.
This list of
mistakes is not comprehensive, but it touches on some of the major errors we
have found in the students’ papers.
Thus, students
for whom English is a second language (ESL) have a keen understanding of how
languages work. However, they have different skills and needs than native
speakers of English. Because they have to deal with competing cultural
expectations and competing languages, ESL students can have special
difficulties seeing problems with their writing and solving them.
Bibliography
1.
“A Guide for Writing Research Papers based on Modern
Language Association (MLA) Documentation.” Arthur C. Banks, Jr. 1998. Library
Capital Community-Technical College. 30 Aug. 1999 – webster.commnet.edu/mla/sample.htm
– Заголовок з екрану.
2.
Boyko A. Using Essay for Developing Creative Writing. 6th National TESOL
Ukraine Conference. – 1991. – 264 с.
3.
Англійська мова. Як уникнути типових помилок=Typical English Mistakes: Довід. для студ., вчителів і тих, хто їде за кордон / Людмила Миколаївна Адамовська (упоряд.), Світлана Андріївна Заїковські (упоряд.). — Тернопіль : Навчальна книга- Богдан, 2006. – 48с.
4.
Казарова Е. И. Writing Practice.
Пособие по развитию навыков письменной
речи: Для студ. гуманит. спец. / Казарова Е. И. – М. : Флинта, 2001. – 80с.
5.
Крівчикова Г.Ф. Посібник
з розвитку англійського писемного мовлення для студентів мовних спеціальностей
(перший рік навчання) / Крівчикова Г.Ф. – Харків: ХДПУ, 2002. – 136 с.
6.
Мазунова Л.К. Письмо на
иностранном языке как предмет обучения / Мазунова Л.К. – М.: Просвещение, 1999.
– С. 68-82.
7.
Мисечко О. Є. Методика навчання
англійської мови в середній школі: Посібник-практикум для студ. вищ. навч. закладів
/ Мисечко О. Є. / Житомирський держ. педагогічний ун-т ім. І.Я.Франка. —
Житомир : Полісся, 2002. – 256с.