Logoveev A.A. Financial
University under the Government of the Russian Federation
Scientific tutor: associate
professor of chair of IE&IB of the FU Silantieva E.A.
The ageing population as a problem of the European
and Russian economies
The article is devoted to the
growing problem of the change of the age structure in most of the world,
particularly in European countries and the Russian Federation.
In the article the author will
provide a comparison analysis of the demographic situation in European counties,
projection of the situation and some conclusions from the analyzed data.
Key words: age, population,
age structure, fertility, mortality, national economy, demographics.
Population ageing is a
global demographic phenomenon, which means that the median age of any given
country keeps rising from year to year [1]. This may be caused by the rising
life expectancy, due to technological progress in medicine, and social care,
and dropping fertility rates, due to women seeking a career, the changes in the
lifestyle of the Western culture and the equalities of women’s rights.
This is the result of long-term demographic changes, changes in the
nature of reproduction, fertility, mortality, their relationships, and partly
migration from country to country. Life expectancy
growth was observed in Europe. The scientific and medical breakthroughs,
expressed in the creation of antibiotics and the spread of immunization
procedures contributed to the growth of the expected length of life. The fall was caused by the use
of antibiotics, which were unknown before the war, better diet – a product of economic growth
– and a large fall in the
incidence of cardiovascular disease. The components of the mortality fall are
as follows. The widespread introduction of antibiotics further reduced adult
mortality. Specifically Russian life expectancy rates grew in the
1980s during the prohibition introduced by Mikhail Gorbachev.[2]
The most important task of population policy is accounting for the
effects of demographic trends and ageing.
With each decade the issue of the ageing population
attracts more and more attention from governments, international organizations
and various other supervising bodies. Issues related to population ageing and the
increasing number of older persons has played a prominent role in the three
major international population conferences organized by the United Nations at
the end of the XX – beginning of the XXI centuries. The International
Conference on Population and Development, which was held in 1994, recognized
that the social and economic impact of population ageing is both an opportunity
and a challenge to all societies. Population ageing is an unprecedented
occurrence. Due to this fact, there is no strict procedure developed so as to
how the governments and social organizations should act and react to this trend
in the changes of the social structure. Increases in the proportions of older persons (60 years or older) are
being accompanied by declines in the proportions of the young (under age 15).
It is estimated, that by 2050, the number of older persons in the world will
exceed the number of young for the first time in history, at least, such are
the United Nations forecasts.
Population ageing is profound, having major
consequences and implications for all forms of human life. In the economic
area, population ageing will have an impact on economic growth, savings,
investment and consumption, difference in labor markets, pensions, taxation and
intergenerational transfers. If we consider the society and its sociological
problems, population ageing affects the healthcare system of countries, causes
changes in family compositions, in the forms of families and their interrelations.
Living arrangements, housing and migration are some of other problems that are
affected by the global population ageing. In the political arena, population
ageing can influence voting patterns and representation. The conservative views
of the older generation, for instance, can overwhelm the views of the younger
generation, especially in developed countries. Thus, to a certain extent, the
author assumes that there will be a contradiction in the political aspect of
the life of the country.
Globally the population of older persons is growing by
2 per cent each year, considerably faster than the world population as a whole.
For at least the next twenty-five years, the older population is expected to
continue growing more rapidly than other age groups. The growth rate of those 60
or older will reach 2.8 per cent annually in 2025-2030. Such rapid growth will
require far-reaching economic and social adjustments in most countries. As the
pace of population ageing is much faster in developing countries than in
developed countries, developing countries will have less time to adjust to the consequences
of population ageing. Moreover, population ageing in the developing countries
is taking place at much lower levels of socio-economic development than was the
case in the developed countries. Today the median age for the world is 26
years. The country with the youngest population is Yemen, with a median age of
15 years, and the oldest is Japan, with a median age of 41 years.
As it has been said earlier, the growth of life
expectancy and falls in mortality and fertility rates lead to the ageing of the
European society. Mortality was reduced due to the decrease in infant mortality
(caused by government intervention and the changes of the ages of women giving
birth) and the fall in adult deaths of infectious diseases. The fall in
fertility was a “Europe-wide phenomenon” [3], caused by the rise of the
opportunities accessible to women on the labour market and the society in
general. The raising of children had a very high cost, because it was perceived
that children prevented their mothers from being able to build a career become
successful in business.
Another aspect of the changing populations is its
influence on pensions. We can look into the experience of various European
countries. The general scheme of European pensions was based on the principle
that taxpayers pay for someone else’s pension and the same people will get
their pensions from other taxpayers when they retire. This scheme connects the existing country’s labour force and the
number of pensioners in need of payments. It also results in the fact that the
reduction of funds results in the increase of the pension age, thus reducing
the number of pensioners to level them up with the labour funds. But, as the
number of pensioners increases and is much higher than the age of working
people, we are at a contradiction and problem: the ever shrinking number of
taxpayers must fund the pensions for the ever increasing number of retirees [4].
But there are some positive economic aspects to this issue. The
demand for manual employment, which could not be undertaken by older people, is
falling relative to the demand for service employment, some of which could.
When the population ages, the participation rate increases. In addition to
that, many older workers have high levels of human capital, a high level of
experience and good traditional education. Population
ageing did not lead to a reduction in expenditure on education, as it might
have, because educational expectations rose.
As the wellbeing of the European society was rising,
the cost of a human life was valued more than ever before, especially more than
before The Second World War. So, people started to pay attention to the
society, human rights and other similar factors. For example, European social
security programs appeared only towards the end of the Industrial Revolution,
but spread after the Second World War. And in the XX century, as worldwide
integration occurred, attention to peoples’ lives also increased, and thus
people lived longer and healthier lives, whereas before that people practically
were left to themselves without outer help. As government involvement expanded,
the population could count on its help and therefore live longer. In all
European countries a decrease in worked hours per year was observed, and this
decrease reflects the improvements in European working conditions. We can
deduct that this innovation was introduced by the governments, because no
employer would deliberately reduce working hours for employees because it would
be inefficient for production and would result in the reduction of the output.
There occurred a decline in total fertility rates
across absolutely all European countries from 1950 to 2005. Even Portugal,
which had the highest fertility rate in 1950 (3.08), by 2005 achieved levels,
which were the same in all countries (1.5 – 1.9). As China grew its population,
Europe did not, partly because of the spread of women’s rights and the openness
of the labour market for women. As women’s rights spread across the world, they
now had to make a choice – either children or build up a career. This way, many
women chose a career over children and the fertility rates lowered. Fertility
remains low up to present day, and the European population growth index
(fertility minus mortality) is close to zero, which shows that the population
is not growing naturally.
The share of
those aged 60 and over has risen from only 8% of the world population (200
million people) in 1950 to around 11% (760 million) in 2011, with the dramatic
increase still ahead as those 60 and over aged people is expected to reach 22% (2
billion) by the year 2050.[5]
These
are some statistical data calculated by the World Economic Forum [6]:
· At the global level, the share of those 80-plus has edged up from 0.6%
of world population in 1950 (15 million) to around 1.6% of world population
(110 million) in 2011, and is expected to reach 4%(400 million) by 2050.
•
The global population is projected to increase 3.7
times from 1950 to 2050, but the number of 60-plus will increase by a factor of
nearly 10, and the 80-plus by a factor of 26.
•
Between 2010 and 2050 the total population will
increase by 2 billion, while the older population will increase by1.3 billion.
•
Women account for about 55% of the 60-plus group,
rising to 64% of the 80-plus group, and 82% of the 100-plus group. On average,
women outlive men by nearly 4.5 years.
Population ageing presents a cultural problem. The
dramatic increase in the numbers of people who are making it to their 80s, 90s
and beyond is generating a profound mismatch between the cultural norms that
guide us through life and the length of our lives. Humans are creatures of
culture. We look to culture to tell us when to get an education, marry, start
families, work and retire.
In the early 1970s the share of pensioners in the
Soviet Union was only 12% of the total population. Now retired people can
account for more than 25% of the population of Russia (over 38 million). The percentage
of elderly people is growing from year to year due to natural wastage - the
nation is aging rapidly, and the trend seems inevitable. Because of the high
mortality and low fertility in 2050, Russia's population could reach a total of
100 million people (instead of 142 million, the current population) [6]. It is
considered that the Russian life expectancy figure is
a special case, with deaths from excessive drinking falling substantially when
Gorbachev increased the price of vodka in 1985 - 1986. During this brief
period, life expectancy grew by three years for males and one year for females.
It also briefly rose (by 5.7 and 3 years) during the economic crisis of 1991–4.
In other words, the further reduction in cardiovascular disease depended partly
on individuals changing their behavior.
Table 1. Population of Russia, 1926 – 2010.
|
1926 |
1939 |
1959 |
1970 |
1979 |
1989 |
2002 |
2006 |
2007 |
2008 |
2009 |
2010 |
Total population |
92681 |
108377 |
117534 |
129941 |
137410 |
147022 |
145167 |
142754 |
142221 |
142009 |
141904 |
141914 |
Population
of a given age: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Younger
than working age |
36854 |
42072 |
35094 |
37145 |
31974 |
35995 |
26327 |
23317 |
22718 |
22497 |
22541 |
22854 |
Working
age |
47830 |
56923 |
68609 |
72752 |
82959 |
83746 |
88942 |
90328 |
90152 |
89752 |
89266 |
88360 |
Older than
working age |
7945 |
9362 |
13827 |
19987 |
22436 |
27196 |
29778 |
29109 |
29351 |
29760 |
30097 |
30700 |
Source: Russian Bureau of Statistics. [7]
We can see from the table that the overall population has been
increasing from 1926 – 1989 and was at a relatively same level from 1989
onwards. But the number of people older than the working age has been
constantly increasing. Using simple mathematical operations, we may calculate
that in 1926 the percentage of people older than the working age of the total
population was 8,57%. In 2010 the same figure was 21,6%. This is a great
increase. We may only conclude that this trend is likely to continue.
Now we shall consider some countries of Europe. Table two has statistical information on all
countries in the European Union, grouped into indicators of 1990 and 2010, a
twenty-year span.[8] Each country is denoted
by a two-letter code. Upon considering this table, we can see that in
absolutely all countries the portion of the population aged 0 – 19 years decreased, at different
rates, but nevertheless decreased. At the same time, the portion of the
population aged over 65 increased in all countries. Though the portion is not
as in Russia (21,6%), Italy and Germany have relatively comparable indicators. Germany
and Italy had the most growth of old population. Germany is the most developed
country, which bailed out Greece during the crisis was most affected by this
problem. But, apart from Germany and Italy, the problem of population ageing is
seen in every country of Europe, it is a ubiquitous occurrence.
Population ageing is a global economic, demographic
and social trend, which affects most countries of the world. Technological
advances of recent decades, such as the invention of antibiotics, heart disease
medicine and etc. etc. have been able to let people live longer lives. If in
the XIX century it was considered normal to die at 50 or 60 years old, now
people may live up to 80 or 90 years and nobody would be shocked, everyone is used
to it. This is regarding the increase of life expectancy.
But the change if the life perceptions have changed during the last 50 years.
The social place of the woman has changed dramatically. Women have equal rights;
they can pursue jobs and careers, not stay at home and be housewives. This delays
the birth of children, some women decline children altogether in favor of
research and careers.
These two forces act reinforcing each other, leading
any country into having an older population. Russia and Europe are no
exception, with a high percentage of people on pensions, and radical policies
are to be implemented in order to change the situation. Basing on the statistical information, we
saw that indeed, this is an ongoing problem, which affects most counties in the
world and has to be given a large portion of the world attention.
List of references:
1.
Medkov V.M.
Demography. - M.,:Infra-M. 2003.
2.
Nikishin A. “Vodka and Gorbachev” – M, All-Russia,
2007
3.
Broadberry S. Cambridge Economic History of Modern
Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University press, 2010.
4.
Conway E. UK's
aging population is a bigger economic threat than the financial crisis // The Telegraph, 12.02.2010,URL: www.guardian.co.uk Date of access 15.10.2012
5. “World Population Ageing 1950-2050” United Nations Report, 2010 URL: http://www.un.org/esa/population/publications/worldageing19502050/, date of access 02.10.2012
6.
“Global Population Ageing: Peril or Promise?”, World
Economic Forum, 2012, URL: http://www.weforum.org/reports/global-population-ageing-peril-or-promise date
of access 02.10.2012
7. Russian
Bureau of Statistics (GKS) URL: http://www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat/rosstatsite/main/,
Access date: 15.11.2012
8. Eurostat.
Demography report 2010, URL: http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/product_details/publication?p_product_code=KE-ET-10-001, Date
of access 15.11.2012