Paweł PODOLSKI, Bogumiła WNUKOWSKA

Politechnika Wrocławska, Instytut Elektroenergetyki

 

Electrical power safety utilizing geothermal sources

 

Abstract. The subjects connected with geothermal sources which are alternatives for conventional fuels, are in the present time unusually essential. In this study, we introduced the main aspects of the utilization geothermal sources for  energetic and industrial aims in the world, and in Poland as well, as the basic arrangements which are used in the exploitation of geothermal sources for the goals of heating and for the preparation of warm usable water.

Keywords: geothermal energy, geothermal systems in heating, energetic safety.

 


 

Introduction

The beginning of the XX century as brought about fast developments of technics and industry. Decades ago, no one knew the results it would bring. Paradoxically, devices that should have provided a better quality of life became at the same time the sources of the world’s biggest problem, which is the pollution of the atmosphere, ground and water. These pollutions are the proximate cause of ill people and animals, lowering crops, necrosis forests, growing barren ground, and also the growing warm climate. Because of the different kinds of pollutions, in some countries it is the deficit of water.

The development of industry has caused an increase for mineral fuels - pit and brown coal, petroleum and earth gas, which supplies have slowly worn out. The intensive exploitation of these fuels, as well as pollution, have utilized a new wider range of sources of energy, such as:

• sun radiation (solar energy),

• energy of splitting the radioactive elements,

• energy of wind, 

• energy of fall of waters (the water energy),

• biomass (the energy of burning the plants),

• geothermal energy (energy of highly active depth waters),

• energy of waters  and oceans.

These sources are characterized by the lack of releasing greenhouse gases and dirt to the natural environment. Special attention needs to be given to the utilization of geothermal sources for heat engineering and the production of electric energy [12].

 

Utilization of geothermal energy in the world

Taking into consideration the current technical possibilities and economic conditioning, over 70 countries possess the resources of geothermal water and steam, which are useful for practical utilization [3]. In 2000, geothermal energy for the production of electric energy was used in 23 countries. Installed power in geothermal power stations carried out about 8000 MW, where the year-old consumption of energy carried out about 50 000 GWh. The most spectacular example of the utilization of geothermal sources is in Iceland, where geothermal energy satisfies 86% of the country’s needs in the range of heat engineering. In developed countries, where a large amount of electric energy is used, power produced from geothermal power stations is marginal by comparison.

Geothermal power stations only fulfill part of the local supplementary sources. Different situations are occurring in developing countries in South and Central America, Asia and Africa, where 70% of the world’s population lives, and where only 25% of electric energy is produced in the world, in this on communal existence 14%, although only a majority of these countries have the resources of high-temperature water and geothermal steams which would enable the obtainment of inexpensive energy. In some of these countries, geothermal energy is already a very important factor in the balance of the prime carrier of energy, and the part of the electric energy obtained from geothermal energy has a strong position.

Direct utilization energy from geothermal water, where the  temperature is low with  averages from 20 to over 1000C, encloses a very wide range of practical application. The principal influence on the possibility of the utilization of energy from geothermal water is the temperature and stage of their mineralisation. Geothermal waters contain dissolved mineral substances, which quantitative type - matter depends on the depth of the covering, temperature, as well as the geological conditions of the geothermal reservoir [10]. The quantity of the produced electric energy and the direct uses of geothermal energy in the world is introduced in table 1. A growing  interest has wakened regarding the generation of electricity in binary systems, which has already been introduced and practiced in Iceland and Austria. Direct uses of geothermal energy is well-known in over 60 countries, such as China, Japan, USA, Iceland, Turkey, New Zealand, Georgia, Russia, France and Hungary.

 

Table 1. Production of electric energy and the direct uses of geothermal energy according to [3]

 

 

Continent

Production of electric energy

Direct uses

Installed

power

Total production

Installed

power

Total production

MW

GWh/year

%

MW

GWh/year

%

Afryka

54

397

1

121

492

1

Ameryka

3 390

23 342

47

5 954

7 266

14

Azja

3 095

17 509

35

5 151

22 532

44

Europa

998

5 745

12

5 630

19 090

37

Oceania

437

2 269

5

318

2 049

4

Razem

7 974

49 262

100

14 174

51 429

100

 

Large quantities of heat are also stored in rocks which do not contain waters or steams, and, they possess high temperatures; they are so called Hot Dry Rock. In several countries, such as France, Germany, Switzerland and Japan, research has been conducted over the ways of regaining the rocks’ warmth. It is also allowed to regain the warmth from the rocks and ground near the surface, from land water and even from river waters, ponds and lakes. However, they posses comparatively low temperatures from several to a dozen or so Celsius stages, and contain warmth that is suitable for  utilization with help of pumps of warmth.

In Poland, as well as other countries, there is a growing interest in these devices for the heating of houses, glasshouses, pools, and water for home use. In Switzerland, for instance, there are already tens of thousands of such installations that deliver warmth to central heating and for the preparation of warm usable water in habitable buildings, and hotels and office buildings.

The opinion of geothermal potential in the world shows that the accessible datum features of useful supplies for the production of electric energy carry out about 12000 TWh/year [1]. Presently, a small percent of this potential is used, though there is a real chance for the enlargement of the production and consumption of electric energy obtained from geothermal steam. Another larger is range of direct utilization of geothermal energy. The available base of useful resources is estimated for 600 thousand EJ. According to prognoses, by the present level of utilization, these resources will be suffice for about 5 million years.

By existing resources and advanced technology, the further development of the utilization of geothermal energy  in individual countries depends on the analyses of profitability and the competitiveness of the market in comparison from different carriers of energy [3]. Electric energy from geothermal steam is produced in 21 countries. Among the countries which produce 10 - 20% of the electric energy from geothermal steams are USA, Philippines, Costa Rica, Salvador and Iceland. Between 1995 and 2000, the growth of the installed electric power from geothermal sources was carried out by 43%. The cost of the production of electric energy is diverse and is most often carried out at 4 cents USD/1 kWh [3].

 

Table 2. Direct utilization of geothermal energy in the world according to [5]

 

 

Use

Installed power

MWt

 

%

Heat production

TJ/rok

 

%

Heat pump

6 849

42,25

23 214

14,33

Heating

4 954

30,56

59 696

36,85

Glasshouses

1 371

8,46

19 035

11,75

Fish farming

525

3,24

10 757

6,64

Dryling agricultural product

69

0,43

954

0,59

Industrial use

494

3,05

10 536

6,50

Recreation and hot water therapy

1 796

11,08

35 892

22,15

Air-conditioning and melting snow

108

0,67

968

0,60

Different

43

0,27

957

0,59

TOGETHER

16 209

100

162 009

100

 

    The range of direct uses of geothermal energy is very wide and contains the heating/cooling, air-conditioning, industry, greenhouse gardening, fish farming, and health resorts (table 2). This kind of logging of energy is characterized with a great reliability and has the important advantages of the technological, economical and ecological. Among the ranges of utilization, heat engineering (37%) predominates; also popular are balneology  and recreation (22%), heat pumps (14%), glasshouses (12%), fish farming (7%) and industry (7%). The directions of farm implements geothermal energy are far-reaching and fully possible in realization, including In Poland. 

The growth of the installed geothermal power in the field of direct utilization in between1995 - 2000 carried out 44%. Recently geothermal energy was the object of interest only  when the supplies of waters or steams achieved high temperatures, which was related with the deep covering of these supplies (3 - 4 km). In the last period, interest in geothermal sources underwent change with the development of applying heat pumps – devices which using ground as bottom source of warmth or place where can accompany excess of warmth in cooling process ( according to time of the year). Heat pumps can be used fundamentally in every country. For instance, in the USA, 400 thousand heat pumps, giving about 4800 MW of thermal energy, a production of energy of 3300 GWh/yahr. The year - old growth of warmth production using heat pumps carries out 10%. Leaders in this trade are Switzerland, Sweden, Germany, Austria and Canada [4]. Geothermal energy, by different renewable sources of energy, such as: the energy of waterfalls, wind and biomass, is competitive in comparison from traditional fuels.

 

Geothermal energy in Poland

Poland belongs to the countries possessing large supplies of geothermal energy which in the majority has  ow enthalpy . In the opinion of experts, geothermal energy should be treated as one of main renewable sources of energy in Poland. Presently, the waters in deposits have temperatures at about 20 to 130 °C, stepping out at depths of 3 - 4 km, and can be used for practical waste management.  We can distinguish three geothermal provinces:

• Province Depression Polish,

• Province Przedkarpcia,

• Carpathian Province;

All of which have extensive geological pools, including numerous reservoirs of geothermal waters geotermalnych (picture 1), with a total surface of about 250 tys. km2 (about 80% of the country’s surface) [6].

 

 

 

Picture 1. Heat engineering geothermal institutions - functioning (1), constructed (2), as well as health resorts applying geothermal waters (3) [6].

 

Interesting conditions also possess waters from Sudety Mountains which are laid in crystalline parties of rocks and in paleozoic [2]. From documentary evidence, supplies of geothermal waters from bore-holes carry out about 50-550 m3/h. Taking under consideration the current prices of traditional carriers of energy, remunerative under the economic point of view is building of geothermal plants and installations for 40% of the surface of the country [7].

Geothermal water was already used in medical care in the XIII and XIV century in Ladek Zdrój and Cieplice. Warm underground waters for treatment and healing cuts were used in Dusznik Zdroj, Ciechocinek, Konstancin,  Ustroń, Iwonicz Zdrój and Zakopanem where there is a large geothermal recreational centre.

In Poland, geothermal energy possesses a large chance of development in the heat engineering and recreation - healing sectors. Particularly important is heat engineering: the central heating, preparation of warm water for home use, as well as agriculture: glasshouses, tunnels, fish farming, drying room, and also – recreation and healing: pools, water parks, rest centres and healing applying geothermal waters.  It will permit considerable limitation of the quantity of burnt carbon, coke, petroleum and gas, as well as connected with the decrease of the dirt of the natural environment.

The wider interest of researching and practical utilization of geothermal energy to heat engineering started in the 1980s. The First Experimental Geothermal Institution Polish Academy of Science started in 1992 on Podhale [9], which opened the way for further work. In 1996, s work started on the second heating geothermal plant in Pyrzyce; ,  a heating plant in Mszczonów in 1999, in Uniejów in 2001, and  in Słomniki in 2002. In Podhale, from few years lasting building of the biggest in Poland and one of the largest In Europe, a heat engineering net which provides for Zakopane. On track for realization is the heat engineering institution in Stargard Szczeciński, also lasting studies of profitability and projects of utilization of geothermal energy. The prognosis and strategies found the local part of geothermal energy in the energetistic market in Poland. Far-reaching field for applying geothermal energy inthe heat engineering, which will contribute to a significant reduction of the quantity of burnt traditional fuels and the release of dirts. In many regions of the country, the geotermice has a real chance for being an essential part in the local heat engineering market. The main advantages resulting from applying the geotermice will be connected with the protection of the natural environment, because it will have a limited quantity of dirt produced by traditional heat engineering systems based on carbon. 

Geotermal energy should be promoted in Poland because  of the requirements placed on the European Union, related to the production of electric energy from renewable sources (until 2010, 7,5% of the renewable energy in the energetic balance of the country).

 

The basic arrangements of geothermal systems in heat engineering

The systems of geothermal installation, which are applied in municipal heat engineering, depend on the parameters of the used geothermal water, as well as the demand for warmth by the recipient. The parameters of geothermal waters on certain areas can be accepted as steady, but the demand of the recipients for warmth is variable and depends on external temperature. Organized graphs of demand for warmth are the basis to projecting geothermal  arrangements. They are helpful for closely establishing the conception and especially near choice of projecting the sources of warmth,    especially of the aggregate of devices to receive the energy from geothermal waters. In dependence from part of geothermal energy in satisfying the heating the recipient's needs, we can distinguish three the basic arrangements of geothermal systems:         

Monowalent arrangement    recipient's heating  needs are fully satisfied through the geothermal heating plant (picture 2), and the power installed in the source is adapted to the maximum demand on the thermal power defined for the computational external temperature.

Picture 2. The block pattern and the well ordered graph of the monowalental arrangement , Q - the demand for warmth, the Qmax - the maximum demand for warmth, the Qgeo - quantity of warmth from geothermics , N - the length of the heat season (days).

 

This arrangement possesses essential defects connected with the low utilization of the flexible power of the geothermal source, which leads to the rise of the costs of warmth. The advisability of applying such arrangement is recommended in the case of high temperatures of water (about 100°C) or cascade utilization of the store of warmth to different technological processes.

 

Biwalent arrangement – geothermal heating plant fulfills the function of the basic source, which works together with  the peak boiler; for instance, gas boiler or oil boiler, when there is a large demand for heat. This arrangement makes for the better utilization of flexible power of the geothermal source for the entire heating period possible.

 

 

Picture 3. The block pattern and the well ordered graph of the biwalent arrangement , Q - the demand for warmth, the Qmax - the maximum demand for warmth, the Qgeo - quantity of warmth from geothermics , N - the length of the heat season (days)

 

For most part of the year, the thermal needs for heat  satisfies geothermal plant and in the peak of the demand for heating starts to work in arrangement with the peak boiler; most often it is an old boiler room (rys. 3).Biwalentny arrangement is, however more expensive.

 

Picture 4. The block pattern and the well ordered graph of the complex arrangement GO – recipients group, Q –the demand for warmth, Qmax – the maximum demand for warmth, Qgeo – quantity of warmth from geothermics, N – the length of the heat season (days)

Complex arrangement – part of the recipients is reinforced through heating plants (low temperature heating) and remaining from conventional boiler rooms (traditional heating). The connection of both systems is made possible at a considerably larger stage of the utilization of the power of the geothermal source and decreasing the cost of warmth production (picture 4). The work of both systems steps out only in colder periods of the heat season, apart from this period, the conventional boilers become extinguished and the geothermal heating plant takes over the production of warmth to heating and the preparation of warm usable water. 

The choice of one of the introduced solutions of the heating plant is made in regards to the techno-economic aspects and the local geothermal conditions, and also the possibility of rational farm implements of geothermal warmth, especially apart from the heat season [8].

 

Summary

The chance for the development of renewable sources of energy: wind, solar radiation, energy of ocean and geothermics, is in the integration of local sources of energy  with regional energetistic structures. Followers of renewable sources of energy should actively co-operate with the very conservative world market of energy. According to investigations over the supplies of energy published by the World Energy Council,  geothermal energy plays a key part (52% of installed power and 80% of electric energy produced from all four renewable sources of energy). Comparatively, a large part of the production of electric energy testifies for the reliability of a power station, for which the coefficient of the duty and accessibility is between 80  to 90% .

From an energetistic safety point of view, it is the geothermal energy. In contrast to the sun’s energy, wind and water is independent from weather and external conditions. It possesses its own possibilities of supplies and it can be used in power stations working on covering basic and peak demand heating. Geothermal energy is:

- ecological -  the application of which does not cause the release of harmful substances (dusts and gasses) to the surroundings,

- abundant - warmth of the ground  accumulated in the deposits of geothermal waters tops many times the quantity of warmth possible from obtainment from mineral fuels and even from different renewable sources of energy,

- renewable - the supplies of ground warmth are so large, that using it at a considerably larger scale than  the present will not cause exhaustion,

- local – it is used in the vicinity of place occurrence, because the highly active waters and steams are not suitable for long transportation for help of pipelines, its deliveries are not dependent on the international political situation which can influence the price of energetistic materials,

- cheaper - in comparison with costs and the prices of electric energy or warmth from traditional mineral fuels, and even from some different renewable sources,

- unfailing - the geothermal energy from the underground deposit of water and steam can be used all year in necessary quantities  [11].

 

Literature

[1]    B j o r n s s o n  J., The potential role of geothermal energy and hydro power in the world energy scenario in                       year 2020,  Proceedings of the 17th WEC Congress 1998.

[2]    D o w g i a ł ł o J., 2001 - Sudecki region geotermiczny 

        - określenie, podział, perspektywy poszukiwawcze. Bocheńska T., Staśko S., (red.) Współczesne problemy hydrogeologii X, Wrocław, 1: 301-307.

[3]    F r i d l e i f s s o n  B., Geothermal Energy for the Benefit of the People Worldwide - Worldwide Overview presented at the World Geothermal Congress, Kazuno Forum, Japan, 28 May - 10 June 2000.

[4]    L u n d  J o h n  W., B o y d  T o n y a  L., Geothermal direct-use in the United States in 2000, Quarterly Bulletin Vol 21 No. 1, March 2000

[5]    L u n d  J o h n  W.,  F r e e s t o n  D e r e k  H., World - wide direct uses of geothermal energy 2000, Proceedings World , Geothermal Congress 2000, Kyushu - Tohoku, Japan, May 28 - June 10, 2000

[6]    R. N e y,  B. K ę p i ń s k a ,  W. B u j a k o w s k i, Present situation of geothermal energy development in Poland 1999- Proceedings of the Europan Geotermal Conference Basel 28-30 September 1999.

[7]    N e y  R., S o k o ł o w s k i  J., Wody geotermalne Polski i możliwość ich wykorzystania, rok wydania 1987   Nauka Polska ,6.

[8]    N o w a k  W., S o b a ń s k i  R., K a b a t  M., K u j a w a T., Systemy pozyskiwania i wykorzystania energii geotermicznej. Wydawnictwo Uczelniane Politechniki Szczecińskiej, Szczecin 2000.

[9]    S o k o ł o w s k i  J., Ważniejsze informacje o wynikach badań geotermalnych na Podhalu ,rok wydania 1991,Technologie Poszukiwań Geologicznych Geosynoptyka i Geotermia, 1/2: 15-20.

[10] http://kmiue.imir.agh.edu.pl/oze/geo/dgeo2.htm

[11]  www.pga.org.pl/ENERGIA_GEOTERMALNA

[12]  www.energia-odnawialna.net/

 

Authors: mgr inż. Paweł Podolski, dr hab. inż. Bogumiła Wnukowska, Politechnika Wrocławska, Instytut Energoelektryki, ul. Wybrzeże Wyspiańskiego 27, 50-370 Wrocław, E-mail: pawel.podolski@pwr.wroc.pl,

bogumila.wnukowska@pwr.wroc.pl