Ýêîíîìè÷åñêèå íàóêè/ 3.Ôèíàíñîâûå
îòíîøåíèÿ.
Lobova Oksana
Graduate student at the department of "insurance and risk managment"
Kyiv National Taras Shevchenko University, Ukraine
Improving of
Ukrainian agricultural insurance on the base of foreign experience
The
agricultural complex is very important for the economy of almost every country.
The risks’ composition in the agricultural sector is due to direct activities
or available resources. They are under the influence of certain events and may be
damaged or be lost. Insurance is an essential risk management tool that allows
you to minimize the loss of farms and make more predictable farmers income. At
present, there is need for the development of comprehensive, specialized
programs of the manufacturers that rely on subsidized financing of insurance.
The main objective of the agricultural insurance in Ukraine is to minimize the
negative outcomes in agriculture from natural disaster, the stabilization of
incomes of farmers in agricultural production, primarily of strategic crops. The
definition of the role of government and insurance companies in the
organization of agricultural insurance and building effective and efficient
relationships between insurance companies and agricultural producers is topical
now.
Prerequisite
for the development of agricultural insurance is a mandatory state
participation in the organization of insurance, which can result in immediate
risk insurance (such form of insurance exists in Greece, Cyprus), and through
support for private insurance (Spain, U.S., Canada). The agricultural insurance
sectors in Spain, the USA and Canada are the largest and most effective. It is necessary
to focus on the international experience while restructuring of Ukrainian
agricultural insurance. The use of which will help to reach the best
achievements in the organization of agricultural insurance, and possibly to avoid
mistakes [4].
International
practice offers a variety of options for the insurance system for agricultural
complex: providing insurance services to private insurance companies without
state aid (Sweden); state participation in reinsurance pools (Spain); subsidizing
premiums for some insurance products, such as hail (France, Austria); providing
financial assistance to cover catastrophic losses (Germany, Italy, USA,
Canada); subsidized insurance programs from many of the risks (multirisk)
(Canada, Russia, USA); creation of a special government agency to implement the
policy in the sphere of agricultural insurance (Spain, Canada, USA, Russia); creation
of an insurance infrastructure [8].
Spain is the
country with the most developed system of agricultural insurance in Europe; it
is built on consensus between insurers, policyholders and the public
administration. In general we can distinguish the following characteristic
features of this system: voluntary insurance of agricultural risks, risk
coverage in the private insurance companies provide on the basis of shared
responsibility (coinsurance), the state supports and develops the system,
farmers are actively involved in decision-making on agricultural insurance [2]
. In Spain, the insurance companies act as agents. All the signed insurance
contracts are transferred to the company (established jointly by the state and
private insurers), which administers contracts, assesses the damage and
benefits. All risks are reinsured through the state reinsurance company. It is offered
more than 100 insurance products for insurance crops and animals. Rates are
calculated by the state. [6]
In the U.S.
federal system of agricultural insurance combined the multirisk insurance
program with the insurance program against catastrophic losses (CAT). All agrarian
programs in the USA are developed by the risk managment Agency, which is
subordinated to the Department of Agriculture and manages the Federal Crop
Insurance Corporation, which collaborates with private insurers. The U.S.
government provides several types of financial support for program management
of subsidized agricultural insurance: premium subsidizing to producers,
compensation administrative costs to insurance companies for the introduction
of subsidized insurance products, financial assistance to cover catastrophic
losses, the financing of operating costs. The disadvantages of this system
include high administrative costs and complexity to control moral hazard [2].
In Canada,
there are specialized "Crown corporation" (public company), which are
the main providers of financial services and insurance services for the
agricultural sector. Private companies offer only a simple insurance products
(hail, some risks). Insurance programs may be voluntary for all manufacturers. Farmers
can choose from several levels of cover and pricing options for insurance
production. The system of financing and insurance of agricultural production is
determined by two main features: broad participation of government lending
programs, and insurance of farmers and integrated approach to risk management
in agriculture [5].
From the
experience of countries with advanced agricultural insurance can be seen that
the most effective form of organization of insurance is the joint participation
of both the state and local budgets, professional associations of manufacturers
and insurance companies. The most effective systems of agricultural insurance
in countries where there are specialized agencies or partnership programs with
private insurance companies. Affiliate programs cost to the government less
expensive and allow private companies to add to the rates of premiums and
administrative expenses percentage of expected profits. The application of
these systems will effectively manage a portfolio of agricultural risks through
their regional diversification and transfer of catastrophic risks to the
international reinsurance market. The relationship between the insurance
companies and the state require special attention. The economic calculations
show that the best form of support is the cost cheapening of insurance premiums
by providing subsidies. This approach is the most effective. This allows using
market mechanisms with more efficient utilization of budget funds. Government
should attract farmers to manage risk, encourage them to apply the best
innovation technology.
The
Ukrainian government should develop a strategic plan for the establishment and
development of agricultural risk insurance, the definition of the role of
government, the type and level of support. In many countries, authorities are
considering the state support of insurance as an investment in agriculture,
which prevent the possible future costs and ensure food security and stability
[1,2].
For
insurance companies, insurance of agricultural risks is a very promising type. But
this type of insurance is highly specialized and has specific sales. Optimal
construction of the organization of agricultural risks’ insurance is to
delegate the sale and appraisal losses on insurance specialists - brokers and agents.
Central role
in this system should belong to the government, which will implement the state
support of agricultural insurance and harmonize the interests of other
participants in the system. It is planned to create the State Agency for
Agricultural insurance in the draft concept, whose functions would include
providing conditions for cooperation of all participants of agrarian insurance,
storage, management and allocation of financial resources, collection and
dissemination of data and information, scientific and statistical research in
the field of market analysis. The government should ensure the stability of the
system, as well as transparency of information. Thus, the draft "Concept
of agricultural insurance development in Ukraine" stipulates the creation
and development of specialized organizations, which will specialize in
agricultural insurance, and in part will remove the burden of organizing and
conducting insurance by insurance companies, which will feature the development
of insurance products, insurance, and implementation reinsurance. It is also need
to create special units that will assist in the development of principles of
good insurance practice and solving problems between insurers and insurance
companies. This saves time and money for manufacturers and insurers. Such
specialized committees exist in Canada (the committee decides 95% of the
agricultural insurance disputes), the Agency's risk management in the U.S. and
"Agroseguro" Spain [8].
For the
effective functioning of insurance it must be created a collective body to
manage the agrarian risks. These agencies operate successfully abroad. For
example, in Canada, a specialized public institution - the Royal corporation
provides services to agriculture, in Spain - The State Agency of Agricultural
Insurance, in Russia - Federal Agency for State Support of insurance in the
agro-industrial production, in the United States - the Agency's risk
management. Taking this into attention, it is appropriate to develop the
National Agency of Agricultural Insurance with state support, which will
provide conditions for the cooperation of all participants of agricultural
insurance, for the accumulation, management, allocation of financial resources
and develop a program of state support for agricultural risk insurance.
In order to
implement an effective system of agricultural insurance you need to create its
institutional components and to develop appropriate legislation acts and to
adopt a separate law on insurance. Thus, in some countries there are government
programs to support farmers. For example, Canada has a number of government
programs to minimize risks and financing farmers: crop insurance program, which
includes net income stabilization program and the program of advancing the
farmers during spring and fall, the provincial support programs for farmers. It
is considered that the Spanish system of agricultural insurance is more advanced,
which is better adapted to the European market. In Spain there is the Law
"On Combined agricultural insurance" which applies not only to crops
but also livestock and forestry.
Bibliography:
1.
The Ukrainian Law project "About agricultural insurance» //www.ifc.org;
2.
The project of the concept "Development of Agricultural Insurance» //www.agroinsurance.
com;
3.
Luzan J. "Insurance Risk Management in Agriculture" journal
"Agrarian Tyzhden"2010/24
4.
Sangadzhieva D. "Crop insurance: Building relationships with the
insurance company” http:http://www.agronews.ru/articleview.php?AId=1545
5.
Yakubovich, the International Finance Corporation "Special status
of the agricultural sector and insurance programs» http://forinsurer.com theme
22
6.
http:// agroua.net / - the portal about the agrarian sector of Ukraine.
7.
http://www.minagro.gov.ua/ - Ministry of Agrarian Policy of Ukraine.